TESE, PESA and testicular biopsy compared — surgical sperm retrieval at Bavishi Fertility Institute
Male infertility

TESE vs PESA vs Testicular Biopsy: Sperm Retrieval Compared

Four different procedures, often used interchangeably in conversation — but chosen for very different reasons. Here's which one suits which situation, and why.

Dr. Parth BavishiDr. Parth Bavishi· Co-director & IVF SpecialistOctober 12, 2026Updated Oct 13, 20268 min read

Medical Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not substitute professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before making any health-related decisions.

TESE, PESA and testicular biopsy compared — surgical sperm retrieval at Bavishi Fertility Institute
Male infertility

TESE vs PESA vs Testicular Biopsy: Sperm Retrieval Compared

~1%

Of men have azoospermia — no sperm in the ejaculate

2 types

Obstructive and non-obstructive, treated differently

Day care

Most retrievals are same-day procedures

ICSI

Retrieved sperm is always used with ICSI

The Short Answer

The right procedure is decided by why there’s no sperm in the semen, not by preference. If sperm is being produced normally but can’t get out — a blockage — it can usually be collected with a fine needle from the epididymis or testicle, quickly and with minimal recovery. If the testicles are producing very little sperm, a needle is likely to miss it, and an open microsurgical search ( Micro-TESE ) gives by far the best chance. Whatever is retrieved is then used with ICSI, because the numbers involved are far too small for any other method.

The Two Types of Azoospermia

Everything about this decision follows from one distinction, so it’s worth being clear about it.

Obstructive azoospermia means production is fine, but the pathway is blocked — from a previous vasectomy, an infection, surgery, or a congenital absence of the vas deferens. Hormone levels are usually normal and the testicles are of normal size. Sperm is there; it simply needs collecting.

Non-obstructive azoospermia means the testicles themselves are producing very little or no sperm. FSH is often raised, testicular volume may be reduced, and a genetic cause is more likely. Sperm may still exist, but only in scattered pockets — which changes the entire surgical approach.

Telling the two apart uses hormone tests, examination, and sometimes genetic testing — and it happens before any procedure is booked. Read more about the underlying condition in our guide to azoospermia treatment.

The Procedures

Four Procedures, At a Glance

Ordered from least to most invasive

PESAA fine needle into the epididymis. No incision, local anaesthesia, over in minutes. First choice when there is a blockage.
TESAThe same needle approach, but sampling the testicle itself. Used when PESA does not yield sperm.
TESEA small incision, with tissue removed and searched by the embryology team. More tissue than a needle, but sampled somewhat blindly.
Micro-TESEAn operating microscope is used to find the fuller tubules most likely to hold sperm. The standard where production is impaired.

PESA — Percutaneous Epididymal Sperm Aspiration

A fine needle is passed through the scrotal skin into the epididymis — the coiled tube where sperm matures and is stored — and fluid is aspirated. No incision, done under local anaesthesia with sedation, and typically over in minutes. Where there is a clear blockage, PESA succeeds in the large majority of cases.

Used for: obstructive azoospermia, as the first choice.

TESA — Testicular Sperm Aspiration

Similar in approach, but the needle samples the testicle itself rather than the epididymis. It’s used when PESA doesn’t yield sperm, or where the epididymis is absent or inaccessible. Still needle-based, still minimally invasive, still same-day.

Used for: obstructive cases where PESA fails or isn’t suitable.

TESE — Testicular Sperm Extraction

This is where "testicular biopsy" comes in — the terms are often used for the same thing. A small incision is made and one or more pieces of testicular tissue are removed and examined by the embryology team for sperm. It samples far more tissue than a needle, but it does so somewhat blindly: tissue is taken from selected areas rather than from areas known to be productive.

Used for: non-obstructive cases, and obstructive cases where needle methods have failed.

Micro-TESE — Microsurgical TESE

The most refined option. Using an operating microscope at high magnification, the surgeon examines the seminiferous tubules directly and selects the fuller, more opaque ones that are more likely to contain sperm. This means less tissue is removed overall, blood supply is better preserved, and the chance of finding sperm in difficult cases is meaningfully higher than with standard TESE.

Used for: non-obstructive azoospermia — where it is the clear standard of care.

Side by Side

Four Procedures ComparedNeedle-Based (PESA / TESA)Open Surgical (TESE / Micro-TESE)
Best suited toObstructive azoospermiaNon-obstructive azoospermia
IncisionNone — fine needle onlySmall incision required
AnaesthesiaLocal with sedationUsually general
Tissue sampledMinimalMore, targeted under microscope in Micro-TESE
Typical recovery1–2 days of tendernessAbout a week of restricted activity
Chance of finding spermHigh, when there's a true blockageBest available option when production is impaired

What Recovery Involves

For needle-based retrieval, most men are back to desk work the next day, with some scrotal tenderness and bruising for a couple of days. For TESE and Micro-TESE, expect about a week of taking it easy — no lifting, no cycling, no gym — with supportive underwear and simple painkillers. Swelling and discomfort that is improving day by day is expected; pain that is worsening, spreading redness, or fever is not, and should be reported straight away.

The Pathway at BFI

Diagnosis first, procedure second, ICSI third

Establish the typeHormone profile, examination and genetic testing where indicated, to separate obstructive from non-obstructive azoospermia.
Match the procedureNeedle-based retrieval where there's a blockage; Micro-TESE where production is impaired and a careful search is needed.
Freeze or use freshRetrieved sperm is used with ICSI, and frozen where quantity allows — so one procedure can cover more than one attempt.

Timing is coordinated with the female partner's cycle where fresh sperm is planned, so both sides of the treatment line up on the day.

SURGICAL SPERM RETRIEVAL AT BFI

All four procedures, one team

Procedures

PESA / TESA / TESE / Micro-TESE

Lab

Class 1000, on site

Freezing

Available same day

Used With

ICSI

Best suited for: Men diagnosed with azoospermia on two separate semen analyses, including those previously told that donor sperm was the only remaining option.

If No Sperm Is Found

This is the possibility every honest discussion has to include. In non-obstructive azoospermia, even a well-performed Micro-TESE does not always find sperm. Knowing this in advance matters — it’s why we discuss the alternative paths, including donor sperm, before the procedure rather than in the recovery room. Being prepared for both outcomes is not pessimism; it is what allows a couple to make the decision calmly.

Do

Have at least two semen analyses confirming azoospermia, including a centrifuged sample.

Complete hormone testing and genetic screening before booking a non-obstructive procedure.

Ask whether the embryology lab will be searching the sample on the same day, on site.

Discuss freezing in advance, so one procedure can potentially serve more than one ICSI attempt.

Avoid

Agreeing to a needle procedure for non-obstructive azoospermia — it's far more likely to miss.

Having the retrieval somewhere the tissue has to be transported to a distant lab.

Skipping genetic testing because the result feels uncomfortable to know.

Assuming a diagnosis of azoospermia rules out biological fatherhood — for many men it doesn't.

The BFI Message for You

Zero sperm in a semen analysis is a starting point for investigation, not a final answer.

We establish the type of azoospermia before choosing a procedure — the diagnosis drives the surgery, never the other way round.

Surgery and embryology happen in the same building on the same day, so nothing is lost in transit.

We talk through what happens if no sperm is found before the procedure, not afterwards.

What to Expect at Bavishi Fertility Institute

Our andrology team performs all four retrieval procedures, and the choice follows from a complete work-up rather than from what is convenient to schedule. Because our surgical sperm retrieval happens alongside an on-site Class 1000 embryology lab, the sample is searched immediately and frozen the same day where quantity allows — which for many men means one procedure rather than two.

Been told there's no sperm in the sample?

The procedure is chosen by the type of azoospermia, obstructive or non-obstructive, and never by preference.

Where there is a true blockage, simple needle retrieval succeeds in the large majority of cases.

Where production is impaired, Micro-TESE gives the best chance and no simpler method matches it.

Retrieved sperm is always used with ICSI, and can usually be frozen so one procedure covers more than one attempt.

Genetic testing before non-obstructive retrieval matters, because some causes can be passed to a son.

A diagnosis of azoospermia does not rule out biological fatherhood for most men.

Been told there's no sperm in the sample?

Book a consultation for a full male work-up — in many cases, biological fatherhood is still possible.

About the Author

Dr. Parth Bavishi

Dr. Parth Bavishi

MBBS, MD (Obstetrics & Gynaecology)

Co-director & IVF Specialist

Dr. Parth Bavishi holds an MD in Obstetrics and Gynaecology and brings over 12 years of specialist experience as Co-director and IVF Specialist at Bavishi Fertility Institute — a group of fertility centres across India committed to helping couples realise their dream of parenthood. His clinical focus is on complex and challenging cases, including male-factor infertility and repeated IVF failure. He has received specialised infertility training at Bavishi Fertility Institute, the Diamond Institute (USA) and the HART Institute (Japan), and is the author of 'Your Miracle in Making: A Couple's Guide to Pregnancy.'

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to start your fertility journey?

Talk to our specialists about your options — no obligation, just honest guidance.